How to Create a Second Baby Registry on Amazon

Have you ever found yourself staring at your baby registry, thinking, "Okay, this worked the first time around, but things are so different now"? I sure did. When I was expecting my second baby, I quickly realized that my old Amazon baby registry wasn’t quite cutting it anymore. The needs were different, the timing was different, and honestly, I was different.

Sound familiar? If you’re in that same boat, you’re probably wondering: Can I create a second baby registry on Amazon? And if so, how? Don’t worry—I’ve been there, figured it out, and I’m here to walk you through the whole thing.

👉 Start Creating Your Second Baby Registry Here 👈

Why You Might Need a Second Baby Registry on Amazon

Before we get into the how-to part, let’s talk about the why. Because if you’re anything like me, you might be feeling a little weird about making another registry. You might be asking yourself, "Is it okay to do this again? Will people judge me?" But let me tell you—you absolutely can create a second registry, and here are some reasons why it makes total sense:

1. Every Baby Is Different

What worked for baby number one might not work for baby number two. Maybe your first hated the baby swing you loved, or you gave away all your baby gear thinking you were done. Been there, done that.

2. Your Needs Have Changed

Your lifestyle might be different now. Maybe you’re in a new home, juggling a toddler while expecting, or just more experienced and know what you actually need.

3. It Helps Friends and Family Know What to Gift

A second registry isn’t just for you—it makes it easier for your loved ones to support you with items you really need.

Can You Have Two Baby Registries on Amazon?

Short answer? Yes! You can absolutely have two baby registries on Amazon. Amazon doesn’t limit you to just one registry per account. In fact, you can create multiple registries for different occasions—baby showers, birthdays, holidays, you name it.

So, if you're wondering how to create a second Amazon baby registry, breathe easy. You're not breaking any rules.

How to Create a Second Baby Registry on Amazon

Now let’s dive into the good stuff. Here’s a simple, step-by-step guide on how to make a baby registry on Amazon when you already have one:

Step 1: Sign in to Your Amazon Account

This might sound obvious, but trust me, when you're pregnant and sleep-deprived, even the simple stuff can feel like a puzzle.

Step 2: Go to the Amazon Baby Registry Page

Once you're logged in, head over to the Amazon Baby Registry homepage. You might be taken to your original registry if you already have one.

Step 3: Archive or Keep Your Old Registry

If you want to keep your old registry for memories or reference, that's totally fine. But if you prefer a fresh start, you can archive it. Either way, you're not deleting anything permanently.

Step 4: Click "Create a New Baby Registry"

Look for an option that says "Create a New Registry" or "Start a New Registry." Click it, and voila! You’re on your way.

Step 5: Fill in the Details

This is where you customize it:

• Due date

• Baby’s gender (if you want to share)

• Shipping address

• Registry privacy settings

Set it up just like you did the first time. Don’t overthink it!

Step 6: Start Adding Items

Now the fun part: adding things to your new registry. Think about what worked last time, what you missed, and what your current lifestyle looks like. A double stroller? New bottles? A baby carrier that’s actually comfortable? Add 'em!

Tips for Making the Most of Your Second Amazon Baby Registry

Creating a second registry is about more than just clicking buttons. Here are some tips to make it really work for you:

Be Honest With Yourself

What do you actually need this time? Don’t feel pressured to add everything. Just the essentials (and maybe a few fun things, too).

Communicate With Loved Ones

If you’re having a sprinkle (a smaller baby shower for second-time moms), share your registry. People want to help, but they need a little direction.

Use the Checklist Feature

Amazon offers a baby registry checklist that helps you make sure you’re not missing anything. It’s a great sanity-saver.

Take Advantage of Amazon Perks

Don’t forget about the benefits that come with creating an Amazon baby registry, even the second time around:

• Welcome Box: Sometimes available for second registries too.

• Completion Discount: Get a discount on remaining registry items before your due date.

• Easy Returns: 365-day returns on registry items.

Common Questions About Creating a Second Baby Registry on Amazon

How many baby registries can you have on Amazon?

Technically, you can create multiple registries. There’s no hard cap, but most people stick to one or two. Just remember to keep things organized so you don’t confuse gift-givers.

Can I use the same email/account to make a second registry?

Absolutely. You don’t need a new email or Amazon account. Just use the same login and start a new registry from your dashboard.

Will people see both registries?

Only if you make them both public. You can choose to keep one private and the other visible, depending on your needs.

Can I transfer items from my old registry?

There isn’t a direct transfer feature, but you can manually add the same items or even just refer to your old list for inspiration.

My Personal Experience: What I Did Differently the Second Time

Let me tell you, my second registry looked very different from my first. The first time, I was wide-eyed and adding every cute onesie I saw. The second time? I was all about practicality.

I skipped the wipe warmer (my baby hated it anyway) and went for a compact diaper caddy that made nighttime changes easier. I swapped out the giant, clunky stroller for a lightweight one I could fold with one hand. And yes, I treated myself to a cozy new rocking chair—because mama deserves comfort too.

And you know what? I enjoyed the process more the second time. It felt less like a to-do list and more like prepping my home and heart for our growing family.

Final Thoughts: Creating Your Second Amazon Baby Registry

So, can you create a second baby registry on Amazon? Yes, yes, and yes. And more importantly, you should if it feels right for you.

This isn’t about being "extra" or asking for too much. It’s about being prepared, feeling supported, and giving your new little one the warmest welcome possible.

Whether you’re expecting a rainbow baby, adding another bundle to your crew, or simply need some updated gear, making a second registry is a smart, simple, and totally acceptable move.

Take a deep breath, grab your favorite snack, and start building your new registry with confidence. You’ve got this—and I’m cheering you on every step of the way. 🍼